Grace Realty Group

Homes Under $4M in Edgartown

Discover beautiful homes for sale under $4M in Edgartown, Massachusetts with Grace Hagerty Real Estate.
20 Peases Pt Way N - Unit 11

20 Peases Pt Way N - Unit 11

Edgartown, MA

2 bedrooms•1.5 baths
$1,932for 3 nights•Oct 4 – Oct 7
87 Schoolhouse Rd

87 Schoolhouse Rd

Edgartown, MA

2 bedrooms•2.5 baths
$2,539for 3 nights•Oct 1 – Oct 4
View Listings

Edgartown Homes Under $4M

Explore the character and appeal of this iconic Martha's Vineyard town.

What Makes Edgartown Special

Blue modern cottage with large glass doors, white deck, and landscaped front yard at dusk

Historic Village Center

Downtown Charm

Two wooden Adirondack chairs on a grassy lawn overlooking a bay with forested shoreline and sandy cliffs

Waterfront Living

Katama's Coastal Appeal

Swimming pool with lounge chairs on wooden deck, surrounded by flowering gardens and wooden fencing, with mature trees in background

Community & Culture

Year-Round Character

Get more when you book direct

Lower prices, every time

Pay less than you would anywhere else. No middlemen or platform fees.

Direct line, real care

Book with the team that actually runs the property. Faster answers, better service, real accountability.

Not just a transaction

We go further for direct guests. We’re building a relationship, not closing a booking.

Frequently Asked Questions

Buying in Edgartown