Homes Under $4M in Edgartown
Edgartown Homes Under $4M
Diverse Neighborhoods
From downtown charm to Katama's quiet character, find your place in Edgartown.
Varied Lot Sizes
Properties range from intimate village settings to expansive grounds with acreage.
Local Market Expertise
Grace Hagerty Real Estate brings 25+ years of Martha's Vineyard knowledge to every transaction.
Explore the character and appeal of this iconic Martha's Vineyard town.
What Makes Edgartown Special
Historic Village Center
Downtown Charm
Waterfront Living
Katama's Coastal Appeal
Community & Culture
Year-Round Character
What Guests Say
Trusted Local Expertise
4.89
176 reviews
We had a lovely stay and hope to return! Perfect location for walking to the ferry and other attractions in Vineyard Haven.
Lauren
Stayed in October 2026
We fully enjoyed our stay. This location was perfect for walking into town, and having a parking space was awesome. We were able to drive all over the island and explore. The place is beautifully decorated and was perfect for the two of us. We would definitely stay here again!
Matthew
Stayed in September 2026
Beautiful location and cozy, charming property. We had a great stay!
Daniel
Stayed in September 2026
The house is great and only a mile from Vineyard Haven.
Virginia
Stayed in September 2026
Get more when you book direct
Lower prices, every time
Pay less than you would anywhere else. No middlemen or platform fees.
Direct line, real care
Book with the team that actually runs the property. Faster answers, better service, real accountability.
Not just a transaction
We go further for direct guests. We’re building a relationship, not closing a booking.
Frequently Asked Questions